REVIEW of The Secret Keeper, by Sandra Byrd

Secret KeeperThe Secret Keeper is the second of Sandra Byrd’s Tudor era books. While the first book, To Die For, provides a refreshing take on Henry VIII’s second wife, Anne Boleyn, The Secret Keeper follows the story of Henry VIII’s  last wife, Kateryn Parr.

Juliana St. John is a young lady gifted with prophecy, and the book opens with a disturbing vision whose meaning she cannot interpret. Through the offices of Thomas Seymour, Juliana becomes a lady-in-waiting to Kateryn Parr and follows her mistress in the journey from being Lady Latimer to becoming the first lady in England.

As Juliana learns to navigate the court, Kateryn navigates her own treacherous waters as the wife of a fickle and unpredictable monarch known for disposing of his queens. A learned woman, Kateryn promotes the Reformation as much as she can but is sometimes forced to hide her inclinations to avoid the king’s displeasure. Juliana meets a dashing young man at court, and in between her duties to the queen, finds time to cultivate this interest.

After the death of King Henry, the story continues with Kateryn Parr’s marriage to Thomas Seymour and the events surrounding them and the young princess Elizabeth who would later become queen. Juliana learns the meaning of the prophecies that are given her and finds a way to intervene to stop evil from occurring.

It took me around a hundred pages to really become absorbed in this book, but once I passed that point, I could not put the book down. Sandra Byrd’s brilliance lies in the way she constructs the plot as the story following the central fictional character to intertwines with and thematically mirrors the stories of known historical characters.

One stock scene in many historical novels is rape–every author seems determined to show how poorly women were treated way-back-when. I was intrigued by the way Sandra Byrd dealt with this topic, however, delving into the question of what responsibility, if any, should be laid at the door of a woman who is assaulted. Without being preachy or anachronistic, she weaves an important lesson into the story and shows us a charitable view of the young Elizabeth, a woman who is often accused of enticing Thomas Seymour.


  1. Interesting review. I’ve been interested in Sandra Byrd for a while, but have not got any of her books. I do however have a birthday coming up….
    I do wonder about certain- circumstances- in history such as the one you mention here. One thing I have come across in the course of historical research was so called ‘ravishment’ in the Middle Ages- which did not actually mean rape in Medieval English law, but ‘abduction’ or ‘kidnapping’. It sounds bad, but it seems on further investigation that it was often used by Feudal wards or their families to escape the control of their guardians and assert their right to freedom of marriage.
    In many court cases, for instance, it appears the so called absentee had consented to their ‘kidnap’= maybe even planned it!

    1. Yes, I tend to think there is a lot more raping going on in historical novels than there was in actual historical fact. This is not to deny that rape did/does happen, but many novels seem to portray it as the norm of medieval life rather than the exception.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s